|
Crozat, Y. and P. Chitapong. 2529. The design of technical improvement in farming systems research: Features of a methodology based on the variability of the technial itineraries performed by farmers. ใน: รายงานการสัมมนาระบบการทำฟาร์ม ครั้งที่ 3 : . ระหว่างวันที่ 2-4 เมษายน 2529 ณ มหาวิทยาลัยเชียงใหม่ จ. เชียงใหม่. น.159-182. |
บทคัดย่อ
Two main approaches to design and testing exist in F.S.R.; a "Top down" approach and a Bottom-up" approach. In F.S.R. in Southeast Asia, design and testing have been dominated by Top-down approaches in which the design of technical, improvements to be tested is assumed from a preliminary site description and mainly concerns the development of new cropping patterns. Testing methods are based on analysis of variance used to compare yield, gross return, ect., of new cropping patterns or superimposed technical components with those of the existing cropping patterns and techniques performed by farmers. Despite its undoubted practicability this approach raises several objections from a methodological point of view.
In "Bottom-up approaches the design is late and is Preceded by an agronomic on-field" survey. This survey uses the existing variability of
technical itineraries and of situations created by farmers as an experimental
design. It aims at an identification and an understanding of the factors that
affect yield elaboration of crops under farmers' conditions, and leads to the
construction of a qualitative model used for the design phase. Technical improvements are designed in order to reach optimum states of the crop defined by the model and to fit to farming systems functioning characteristics.
(farmers decision making, labour availability... )
During the testing, an analysis of the differences between the results and the predictions from the model is used to improve the design of techniques and the model.
Some features of the agronomic on-field survey are illustrated with data from a F.S.R. project carried out in the Songkhla Lake Basin (Southern
Thailand). The notion of variability and its usefulness for experimental
design is developed, The principles of analysis of such an experimental
design are described and guidelines for the construction of a qualitative
model presented and discussed.
|
|
|